Finding Strength in Difference: SMPs and the Big 4 Aren’t the Same Game

Small and Medium-Sized Practices (SMPs) have long played a crucial role in the accounting and auditing ecosystem, offering personalized services to smaller businesses. However, the advent of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and advanced technologies has ignited debates about whether SMPs can—and should—strive to match the quality of the Big 4 accounting firms. While technology can certainly help bridge the gap, SMPs should focus on enhancing their unique strengths rather than replicating the Big 4’s model.

SMPs and the Big 4: Different Contexts, Different Strengths

The Big 4—Deloitte, PwC, EY, and KPMG—operate on a global scale, serving multinational corporations and offering an extensive range of services. Their dominance stems from vast resources, cutting-edge technology, and global networks. By contrast, SMPs focus on small and mid-sized businesses, excelling in agility, personalized service, and local expertise.

Attempting to match the Big 4’s scale and processes is neither practical nor necessary for SMPs. Instead, SMPs should leverage their strengths while integrating AI to complement their services, enhancing efficiency and quality without sacrificing their identity.

How AI Can Bridge the Quality Gap Without the Stress

AI offers SMPs an opportunity to close the quality gap with the Big 4 in key areas, including automation, data analysis, fraud detection, and compliance.

1. Automating Routine Tasks

AI can take over repetitive tasks, allowing SMP professionals to focus on strategic work. For example, AI-powered tools streamline data entry and reconciliation, reducing errors and saving time. Similarly, Optical Character Recognition (OCR) and Natural Language Processing (NLP) can review contracts and invoices for compliance, accelerating document analysis.

2. Enhanced Data Analysis

The Big 4 leverage sophisticated analytics to assess entire datasets. SMPs, however, can adopt affordable AI tools to identify anomalies in transactions, provide predictive risk insights, and generate real-time dashboards. These tools offer actionable insights, enabling SMPs to deliver enhanced decision-making support to clients without requiring extensive infrastructure.

3. Improving Fraud Detection

Fraud detection is an area where AI excels. Machine learning algorithms analyze historical data to uncover unusual patterns and transactions. SMPs can integrate such tools to strengthen fraud prevention, offering a higher standard of assurance to clients.

4. Scaling Compliance

Regulatory requirements evolve rapidly, and AI tools can help SMPs stay compliant by automatically updating checklists and workflows. This reduces the manual burden on staff and allows SMPs to deliver reliable compliance services on par with the Big 4.

5. Affordable Technology Solutions

Unlike the Big 4, which invest heavily in proprietary systems, SMPs can rely on cost-effective, cloud-based platforms like Xero, QuickBooks, and AI-driven analytics tools. These solutions provide scalability and advanced capabilities without significant financial strain.

Finding Strength in Difference

While AI helps SMPs close certain gaps, their real strength lies in their distinctive qualities. SMPs thrive by building long-lasting client relationships, offering tailored solutions, and leveraging deep local market expertise. They also provide affordable services that small businesses can rely on.

Instead of mimicking the Big 4, SMPs should use AI to enhance their unique qualities, positioning themselves as valuable partners to smaller clients who seek personalized attention and localized expertise.

The SMP Advantage in the AI Era

Jean Stephens, CEO of RSM International, aptly stated, “SMPs don’t need to be the Big 4. They need to be the best at what they do.” By embracing AI, SMPs can deliver more efficient, accurate, and innovative services while retaining their core strengths.

The future of SMPs lies not in becoming the Big 4 but in redefining excellence on their own terms. With AI as a partner, SMPs can bridge the quality gap, enhance client service, and secure their place in an evolving market.

References

Deloitte Insights: “AI in Auditing—Transforming the Profession.”
PwC Global: “Harnessing AI for Auditing Efficiency and Accuracy.”
Vasarhelyi, M. “Auditing in the Age of Automation,” Rutgers Business School, 2023.
Stephens, J. (2024). “The Role of SMPs in a Changing Audit Landscape,” RSM International.
EY Report: “Transforming Auditing with Helix Analytics.”
Jagolinzer, A., Cambridge Judge Business School: “Transparency and Ethics in AI Use,” 2024.

Comments

Beyond Double-Entry: Blockchain and the Evolution of Accounting

How blockchain technology is reshaping transparency, efficiency, and trust in the accounting profession. Accounting at a Crossroads For centuries, double-entry bookkeeping has been the foundation of modern accounting. First developed in the 15th century by Luca Pacioli, this method revolutionized financial recordkeeping by introducing a system of checks and balances. Yet, even this historic innovation is not immune to the pressures of the digital age. Enter blockchain technology—a disruptive force reshaping how we think about trust, accuracy, and transparency in financial transactions. Much like double-entry bookkeeping transformed accounting, blockchain introduces a paradigm shift: triple-entry accounting. This system incorporates blockchain’s immutable ledger as a single source of truth, enabling a new level of accountability and efficiency. This article explores how blockchain technology is driving the evolution of accounting, the challenges it poses, and how accountants can ...

USAID is Finally "Dead": What’s the Implication for Africa?

This article is a follow-up to my previous piece, Trump and Musk’s America: A Billionaire-Led Revolution and Africa’s Defining Moment , where I explored the shifting dynamics of American leadership and its impact on Africa. With the increasing privatization of global influence and the decline of traditional institutions like USAID, Africa faces a critical turning point. For decades, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) has been a dominant force in global development, particularly in Africa. Through billions of dollars in aid, humanitarian assistance, and economic development programs, USAID has played a key role in shaping policies, funding critical infrastructure, and supporting democracy-building initiatives across the continent. However, with recent shifts in U.S. foreign policy, reduced political will, and global financial constraints, the agency is experiencing a significant decline. But what does the "death" of USAID really mean for Africa? Th...

The Impossible Revival? Why Andersen Consulting’s Comeback Faces Unprecedented Challenges in Today’s Consulting Landscape

The revival of Andersen Consulting under the auspices of Andersen Global has reignited debates about the viability of resurrecting a brand that once epitomized excellence in consulting. As reported by the Financial Times (FT), Andersen Global is strategically leveraging the historical reputation of Andersen Consulting to re-enter a transformed market dominated by firms like Accenture, McKinsey, Deloitte, and Boston Consulting Group (BCG). However, a deeper analysis reveals significant challenges in reclaiming leadership in the consulting industry. From its lack of differentiation to an unproven leadership team and a legacy of ethical controversies, Andersen Consulting’s revival faces an uphill battle. THE RISE, FALL, AND LEGACY OF ANDERSEN CONSULTING Arthur Andersen’s downfall stemmed from its complicity in the Enron accounting scandal, one of the largest corporate frauds in history. Andersen’s auditors were found to have knowingly approved misleading financial statements, l...

ISSA™ 5000: A New Era for Sustainability Assurance

The International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB) has ushered in a transformative chapter in corporate reporting and assurance with the release of International Standard on Sustainability Assurance (ISSA™) 5000 – General Requirements for Sustainability Assurance Engagements. This landmark standard, approved in 2024, is designed to provide a comprehensive and globally applicable framework for the assurance of all sustainability-related information. The Rise of Sustainability Assurance As environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues dominate stakeholder expectations and regulatory landscapes, the demand for credible, consistent, and comparable sustainability reporting has soared. However, this growing demand has highlighted a fragmented assurance environment, with varying standards, scopes, and levels of assurance being applied across jurisdictions and industries. Recognizing the need for clarity and global consistency, the IAASB developed ISSA 5000 as a foundational...

Trump and Musk’s America: A Billionaire-Led Revolution and Africa’s Defining Moment

Introduction: The Moment Africa Has Been Waiting For Africa is at a turning point. For decades, foreign powers have exploited the continent’s vast natural resources while African nations remained dependent on foreign aid, imports, and external control. However, for the first time in modern history, all global superpowers are too distracted to focus on Africa. The United States, under Donald Trump, is focused on domestic economic protectionism, reducing foreign aid, and bringing manufacturing back home. With Elon Musk reshaping key industries from energy to technology America’s shift towards self-reliance is accelerating. Europe is struggling with economic recession, rising immigration crises, and internal political instability. China, once Africa’s dominant economic partner, is battling economic slowdowns and trade conflicts with the West. Russia is fully engaged in war, prioritizing military spending over global economic expansion. Meanwhile, some African nations especially in Francop...

A Deep Dive into ISA 240 (Revised): The Auditor’s Responsibilities Relating to Fraud

In recent years, financial scandals and corporate failures have reignited global attention on the auditor’s role in detecting fraud. Stakeholders—including regulators, investors, and the public—are increasingly questioning whether auditors are doing enough to detect and respond to fraudulent activities during financial statement audits. In response to this concern, the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB) has taken a significant step to strengthen the expectations and responsibilities of auditors with the proposed revisions to International Standard on Auditing (ISA) 240 . Background The existing ISA 240, titled "The Auditor’s Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements," outlines the auditor’s obligation to obtain reasonable assurance that financial statements are free of material misstatement, whether caused by error or fraud. However, increasing complexity in financial reporting, evolving fraud schemes, and public scru...

The PwC Layoffs and What They Signal for Careers at the Big Four: Trends, Triggers, and a Wake-Up Call for Early Professionals

In early May 2025, PwC confirmed the layoff of approximately 1,500 U.S. employees, representing about 2% of its domestic workforce. While the Big Four firm stressed that this was a difficult but necessary decision, the move has sparked wider concerns within the accounting and professional services industry. For young professionals and aspiring accountants, this moment is more than a headline—it's a warning signal. This article explores the rationale behind the layoffs, the core causes driving the trend, the demographics of those impacted, and why Deloitte, KPMG, and EY are likely to follow suit before the year ends. Most importantly, it provides practical advice to those pursuing careers within the Big Four in this rapidly evolving landscape. Understanding the Rationale PwC attributed the decision to historically low levels of attrition and strategic workforce realignment. In essence, not enough people were leaving on their own, leading to staffing levels that outpaced actual ...

Fintech and Beyond

Search This Blog